Skip to Content Find it Fast

This browser does not support Cascading Style Sheets.

Robert Frost Farm
Web site funded by:
Center for New England Culture

Frost Farm Prize - Winning Poem


Caitlin Doyle Wins 7th Annual Frost Farm Prize

Winner reads at Frost Farm June 16

Caitlin Doyle image

May 2, 2017, DERRY, NH -- The Trustees of the Robert Frost Farm in Derry, NH, and the Hyla Brook Poets today announced that the winner of the 7th Annual Frost Farm Prize for metrical poetry is Caitlin Doyle of Cincinnati, Ohio, for her poem, "Wish."

The prize was judged by Deborah Warren, a recipient of the New Criterion Poetry Prize and the Richard Wilbur Award. Doyle receives $1,000, and publication in The Evansville Review. She will also be a featured reader at The Hyla Brook Reading Series at the Robert Frost Farm in Derry, NH, on Friday, June 16, 2017, 7:00pm. The reading kicks off the third annual Frost Farm Poetry Conference (June 16-18, 2017). 
Commenting about this year’s winning poem, Warren said, "This poem is a masterpiece masquerading (with its incantatory beat and simple language) as a Mother Goose rhyme. It’s also that rare poem where the form is integral to the story. Each of the first four trimeter couplets expresses one of the speaker’s wishes. Each line begins with ‘I told him I needed’ . . .). The final three couplets look back on the wishes with wrenching regret. Following each little couplet is a parenthesis: one tetrameter line explaining why the wish, although granted, ironically failed. The parentheses play on the idiom ‘wishing for the moon’. They rhyme, and—taken by themselves—collectively make a poem in their own right.  On the other hand, if you do remove these parentheses, the seven trimeter couplets themselves make up an unrhymed sonnet—with a conventional volta between the octave and the sestet. It’s the poem’s tone that is so sad. The deceptively nursery-rhymish repetitions (I told him in the octave; Now I have in the sestet) only emphasize the speaker’s desolation." 
Doyle’s poetry, essays, and reviews have appeared or are forthcoming in The AtlanticBoston Review, The New CriterionThe Los Angeles Review of BooksThe Threepenny Review, and others. Her poetry has also been featured through the PBS NewsHour Poetry Series and the Poetry Foundation’s “Poem of the Day” series. Doyle has held Writer-In-Residence teaching positions at Penn State, St. Albans School, and Interlochen Arts Academy. Her awards and fellowships include residencies at the Yaddo Colony, the James Merrill House, and the MacDowell Colony, as well as an Amy Award in Poetry through Poets & Writers. She has received scholarships through the Bread Loaf Writers’ Conference, the Association of Writers & Writing Programs, and the Sewanee Writers’ Conference, among others. She is currently an Elliston Fellow in Poetry at the University of Cincinnati, and she will serve as the Assistant Editor of The Cincinnati Review this upcoming fall. To learn more about her background and writing, you can visit her website at
Doyle described her reaction to being selected as the winner: "I’m honored to be chosen as the winner of the Frost Farm Prize. Robert Frost is one of the first poets who entranced me in childhood, and he has remained a major figure in my reading life. Whenever I teach poetry, I start the first day of class with a focus on his poem ‘Birches,’ which I’ve always regarded as one of the most stirring and masterful poems in the English language. My hope is for students to feel in their bodies the way that the rhythm of the poem mirrors its narrative movements and emotional contours. I’m thrilled to have the opportunity to spend time this summer at the Frost Farm in Derry, where Frost wrote many of his most compelling poems, and I hope to glimpse some New Hampshire birch trees through the window of the barn." 
The judge read all 763 anonymous entries and, in addition to selecting the winner, chose two poems as Finalists.


I told him I needed time – he gave me a cuckoo clock (I couldn’t work the winding key) I told him I needed space – he gave me a telescope (or make the moon look back at me) I told him I needed change – he gave me a penny jar (or stop from spending every cent) I told him I needed more – he led me to the well (or count up every wish I’d spent) Now I have so much time, the cuckoo’s flown away (the moon’s a clock that’s come unwound) Now I have so much space, it’s night for days on end (the moon’s a shadow on the ground) Now I have so much change, the well’s just one more wish (the moon’s a coin the well has drowned)    --Caitlin Doyle

About Frost Farm Poetry

Frost Farm Poetry’s mission is to support the writing and reading of poetry, especially metrical poetry. The Hyla Brook Poets started in 2008 as a monthly poetry workshop. In March 2009, the monthly Hyla Brook Reading Series launched with readings by emerging poets as well as luminaries such as Maxine Kumin, Sharon Olds and Richard Blanco. From there, the Frost Farm Poetry Prize for metrical poetry was introduced in 2010, with the Frost Farm Poetry Conference beginning in 2015.

For further information, email, or visit or or